Macaque Consulting

Nearshore Outsourcing Companies in Spain: How to Compare and Choose

Xavier JiménezNovember 16, 2026

Search for nearshore outsourcing companies and you will find dozens of providers in Spain and across Europe making the same promises: senior talent, fast onboarding and total flexibility. On paper they look very similar. In practice, choosing the wrong one is expensive: people who do not fit, constant turnover, a contract that is hard to leave or a compliance gap that nobody mentioned.

This guide gives you a step-by-step method to compare nearshore outsourcing companies in Spain, plus a vendor scorecard you can copy into a spreadsheet. If you first want to understand how nearshore software development works, why Spain and what it costs, start with our complete guide to nearshore software development in Spain. A note on transparency: Macaque Consulting also provides IT outsourcing services, and this method works for comparing any provider, including us.

Choosing a nearshore outsourcing company in 60 seconds

  • Start with your needs, not the provider: define scope, engagement model, roles, duration and security requirements before asking for proposals.

  • Build a shortlist: from a longlist of 8 to 10 companies, keep 3 to 5 after a first screen against your minimum requirements.

  • Ask everyone for the same thing: a request for proposal (RFP) with the same scope and the same response format, so the proposals can be compared.

  • Score with a weighted scorecard: criteria weighted for your engagement model, a 1 to 5 scale and pass/fail requirements.

  • Verify what you are told: valid certificates with the right scope, references from current clients and interviews with the people who will actually work with you.

  • Test before you commit: a pilot with success criteria and a contract with a clear exit.

Types of nearshore outsourcing companies

Very different providers sit under the "outsourcing company" label. If you compare them without telling the types apart, you end up comparing things that are not alike.

Type of company

A good fit when…

Watch out for…

Large consultancy or systems integrator

You need large volumes, an international footprint or a transformation programme that involves many areas.

Whether the team in the proposal is the team you get, turnover and flexibility when things change.

Mid-sized technology consultancy

You want stable teams with their own management and direct access to senior people.

Their real capacity to grow with you and their depth in your technology.

Specialist boutique

You need deep experience in a specific technology or industry, such as data, AI or an ERP.

Dependence on a few key people and how they cover replacements.

Staffing-led provider

You only need to fill a one-off vacancy quickly.

Whether there is any management or service behind the CVs. If the provider only supplies people, all the coordination falls on you.

Freelance platform

You have well-defined tasks and an in-house team that can direct and review the work.

Continuity, intellectual property and who is accountable when something goes wrong.

Offshore provider

Price is the top priority and the work needs little real-time coordination.

Time zone differences, language, data transfers outside Europe and the cost of coordination.

No type is better in the abstract. What matters is comparing companies of the same type or, when you compare different types, knowing what you gain and lose with each. Our nearshore guide explains how nearshore compares with onshore and offshore.

Before you compare: write a one-page brief

Many comparisons fail before they start: each provider hears a different explanation, proposes something different, and you end up comparing the prices of services that have nothing in common. A one-page brief prevents that. It should cover:

  • Goal: the problem you want to solve and how you will know it is solved.

  • Scope: what is in and out, and which part stays with your team.

  • Engagement model: staff augmentation, dedicated team, fixed-scope project or managed service. If you are unsure, ask providers to propose one and justify it.

  • Roles and technologies: roles, seniority, tech stack and tools.

  • Ways of working: remote, hybrid or with on-site visits, overlap hours with your team and working language.

  • Duration and volume: start date, expected duration and how the team may grow or shrink.

  • Security and compliance: which personal data will be processed, which certifications you require and which rules apply to your sector, for example DORA if you are an EU financial entity.

  • Budget: at least a range. Without one, you will get proposals that cannot be compared.

How to compare nearshore outsourcing companies step by step

A simple, orderly process beats a huge tender that nobody has time to read. These are the steps we recommend.

1. Build a longlist

Gather 8 to 10 companies: recommendations from your network, providers with case studies in your industry or technology, members of industry associations and search results. At this stage, their website, published case studies and size are enough.

2. Screen against minimum requirements

Before asking for proposals, rule out anyone who does not meet the essentials: experience in your technology, working language, capacity for the volume you need, required certifications and financial stability. Many large companies call this stage supplier qualification: procurement approves the provider before it can bid. A short request for information (RFI) or a 30-minute call is enough for this screen.

3. Request proposals in the same format

Send the brief to the 3 to 5 companies left, with a deadline and a common response template: approach, proposed team with named people, onboarding plan, service governance, itemised pricing and terms. If each provider answers in its own way, the comparison ends up depending on who presents best.

4. Interview the people, not just the salesperson

Ask to meet the people who will work with you: the proposed engineers and the provider's delivery manager. A short technical interview or a practical test tells you more than any CV.

5. Score with the scorecard

Each member of the selection panel scores independently using the template in the next section, and then you compare the scores. That way, neither the loudest voice nor the slickest presentation decides.

6. Call references and run a pilot

With the two finalists, speak to current clients and, if possible, start with a small pilot before signing a long contract.

7. Negotiate the contract

With the chosen provider, agree pricing, service level agreements (SLAs), replacements, intellectual property, data protection and exit terms. Our nearshore guide covers what the contract should include.

Vendor scorecard template: a weighted evaluation matrix

This is the core tool for comparing nearshore outsourcing companies. The weights depend on the engagement model: in staff augmentation, the quality of the people matters most; in a fixed-scope project or a managed service, what matters most is the provider's ability to organise the work and be accountable for the outcome.

Criterion

What you assess

How you check it

Weight for staff augmentation

Weight for a project or managed service

Technical fit and experience

Experience in your technology and industry, comparable case studies

Case studies with data, technical interview and references

20%

15%

Quality of the people

Real level of the proposed engineers and how the provider selects them

Interviews and a practical test with the proposed people

25%

10%

Management and governance

Delivery manager, reporting, KPIs and how issues are escalated

Governance model in the proposal and a sample status report

10%

20%

Security and compliance

Certifications, data protection, access management and the rules of your sector

Verified certificates, data processing agreement and security questionnaire

15%

15%

Total price and terms

Total contract cost, what is included, minimum commitments and rate reviews

Itemised pricing in the same format for everyone

15%

15%

Team continuity

Turnover, replacement policy, overlap period and documentation

Turnover data, contractual replacement times and references

5%

10%

Communication and ways of working

English level, overlap hours, methodology and cultural fit

Interviews and meetings during the proposal stage

5%

5%

Company strength

Track record, financial position and dependence on a few clients

Filed annual accounts and references

5%

10%

How to score

  • 1 to 5 scale: 1, does not meet the requirement; 2, meets it with significant gaps; 3, meets it; 4, meets it well and proves it; 5, stands out and backs it up with evidence.

  • Final score: multiply each score by its weight and add up the results. The maximum is 5.

  • Pass/fail requirements: must-haves, such as a certification your sector requires or the working language, are not scored. Either the provider meets them or it is out, however well it scores elsewhere.

  • Only count what can be checked: if a claim comes without evidence (a case study, a certificate or a reference), score it as if it did not exist.

  • Adapt the weights to your case: the ones in the table are a starting point. Set yours before the proposals arrive, not after.

A worked example

Imagine three companies competing for a staff augmentation engagement. The scores are fictitious and only illustrate the calculation.

Criterion (weight)

Company A

Company B

Company C

Technical fit (20%)

4

3

5

Quality of the people (25%)

4

3

4

Management and governance (10%)

3

4

3

Security and compliance (15%)

4

5

2

Total price (15%)

3

5

3

Team continuity (5%)

4

2

4

Communication (5%)

4

3

4

Company strength (5%)

4

4

3

Final score (out of 5)

3.75

3.70

3.60

B is the cheapest and the strongest on security, but it finishes behind A because its engineers score lower, and in staff augmentation that carries the most weight. C has the best technical fit, but if your sector requires a certification it does not hold, its 2 on security would rule it out and its final score would not matter. When the gap is as small as the one between A and B, references and the pilot decide.

How to compare prices without fooling yourself

The hourly or day rate is the easiest figure to compare and the most misleading. To compare properly, work out the total cost of each proposal over the same period, for example 12 months, and ask every provider the same questions:

Question

Why it matters

What does the rate include?

Management, the delivery manager, replacements, training, equipment and licences may be included or billed separately.

Is there a minimum term or volume commitment?

A low rate with a long lock-in can cost more than a higher rate without one.

How are rates reviewed?

An uncapped annual increase changes the cost of year two.

What does onboarding or replacing someone cost?

Some providers charge for the onboarding period or for the overlap during a replacement.

What is billed on top?

Travel, work outside agreed hours, on-call cover, tools and currency costs if you are invoiced in euros.

What does it cost to exit?

Notice periods, penalties and the cost of handing knowledge over to another team.

With those answers, the maths is simple: total cost = rates for the period + billable extras + estimated onboarding and exit costs. It is common for the rate gap between two proposals to disappear, or reverse, once you add these items.

How to verify what nearshore outsourcing companies tell you

In a proposal, everyone has senior talent, low turnover and certified security. This is what to check and how:

  • ISO/IEC 27001: ask for the certificate and check that it is valid, that it was issued by an accredited certification body and that its scope covers the service you are buying, not just one office or department. It must be the 2022 version: certificates under the 2013 version expired or were withdrawn after 31 October 2025. You can confirm it with the issuing body or in the IAF CertSearch database.

  • Data protection: if the provider will process personal data on your behalf, both the GDPR and the UK GDPR require a written contract with the processor (Article 28). Ask for their data processing agreement and their list of sub-processors.

  • Your own regulations: if your organisation falls under NIS2, the directive requires you to manage the security of your supply chain, including your direct suppliers (Article 21). If you are an EU financial entity, DORA sets the minimum terms for contracts with ICT service providers (Article 30).

  • How they employ their people: ask whether the team are employees or contractors, and who manages their day-to-day work. A provider that only supplies CVs leaves all the management to you.

  • Company strength: Spanish companies file their annual accounts with the Companies Register (Registro Mercantil). Ask for them, and ask how much of the provider's revenue comes from its largest client.

  • People: ask for the proposal to name the people you interviewed and for the contract to say what happens if they do not join.

  • Case studies: ask for specifics (team, duration and results) and a client contact. A logo on a website is not a reference.

What to ask client references

A 20-minute call with a current client is worth more than any presentation. Ask to speak to someone who works with the provider now, on a service similar to yours, and ask them:

  1. What service do they provide, since when and with how many people?

  2. How many people on the team have changed in the last year, and how were the replacements handled?

  3. Were the people you were introduced to the ones who actually joined?

  4. How do they respond when something goes wrong? Can you tell me about a real problem and how it was solved?

  5. Do they meet deadlines and service levels? How do you measure that?

  6. Have there been any surprises on the invoices?

  7. What would you improve about the service?

  8. Would you hire them again?

The pilot: test before you sign long term

If two providers are very close, or the contract is large, a pilot reduces the risk. Some guidelines:

  • Keep it small: a specific goal, a small team and a short duration, for example four to eight weeks.

  • Define success up front: deliverables, quality, deadlines and how the team communicates.

  • Pay for it: a free pilot tends to get lower priority and does not reflect the real service.

  • Plan the exit: make clear what happens to the code and documentation if you do not continue.

  • Assess it with the same scorecard: replace promises with what you have seen.

Common mistakes when comparing nearshore outsourcing companies

  1. Comparing hourly rates instead of the total contract cost.

  2. Requesting proposals without a common brief and ending up comparing different things.

  3. Deciding on the strength of the sales pitch without interviewing the people.

  4. Taking a certification at face value without checking that it is valid and what it covers.

  5. Hiring individual contractors and managing them as if they were your own staff.

  6. Setting the criteria weights after seeing the proposals.

  7. Forgetting the exit: notice periods, knowledge handover and code ownership.

  8. Not asking for turnover data or a written replacement policy.

Frequently asked questions about nearshore outsourcing companies

How many nearshore outsourcing companies should I compare?

Three to five at the proposal stage. With fewer, you lose perspective on prices and approaches; with more, the process drags on and a detailed comparison becomes hard. Before that, you can start from a longlist of 8 to 10 and screen it against your minimum requirements.

What certifications should a nearshore IT outsourcing company have?

It depends on your sector and the data involved. ISO/IEC 27001 is the benchmark for information security, and it is worth requiring if the provider will access your systems or data. Always check that the certificate is valid and that its scope covers the service you are buying.

Is a large provider or a specialist better?

Neither is better by definition. A large provider brings volume and reach; a mid-sized or specialist provider usually offers more stable teams and direct access to senior people. Decide based on your needs and score them all with the same scorecard.

How do I know if a nearshore outsourcing company is reliable?

By what you can check: references from current clients, verified certificates, turnover data, filed accounts and a pilot. If a provider cannot or will not share that information, that is an answer in itself.

What is the difference between nearshore and offshore outsourcing?

Nearshore means working with a provider in a nearby country with a similar time zone, such as a Spanish partner for a company in the UK or elsewhere in Europe. Offshore means a distant country with a large time difference. Mainland Spain is on Central European Time, one hour ahead of the UK. Our guide to nearshore software development compares both in detail.

What is an RFP and when do I need one?

A request for proposal (RFP) is the document you use to ask several providers for a proposal with the same scope and format. For a small staff augmentation engagement, a one-page brief and a response template are enough. For large contracts or regulated sectors, use a more formal RFP reviewed by procurement and legal.

Sources

Want to apply this in your company?

Our team helps you put it into practice.

Explore our IT outsourcing service

Xavier Jiménez

CEO and Co-Founder of Macaque Group

7 posts

CEO and co-founder of Macaque Group, a technology group based in Calafell (Tarragona, Spain) that specialises in artificial intelligence, software development and IT outsourcing. He advocates AI without the hype: AI that solves real business problems, delivers measurable results and makes it into production. He is a member of OdiseIA, the Spanish observatory on the social and ethical impact of AI, and has been published in Capital Humano (Wolters Kluwer).

Related posts

See all posts

Certifications

ISO/IEC 27001:2023
EUROCERT S.A. Certificate no. 00.15.0812

Open Macaque Consulting ISO/IEC 27001:2023 certificate

Certification corresponding to Macaque Consulting
Scope according to certificate.

We process your personal data in accordance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and Organic Law 3/2018 (LOPDGDD). See our Privacy Policy.

Open Macaque Consulting ISO/IEC 27001:2023 certificateObtained
ISO 27701
In progress
ISO 9001
In progress
ENS ALTO
In progress
ISO 42001
Under review

Members of

  • FEGP
  • OdiseIA
  • PIMEC
  • TICSud

Let's talk about your project

Tell us what you need and we'll reply within 24 working hours.

We drive your business with technology and artificial intelligence

Personalised advice

We analyse your case and propose solutions tailored to your business

Continuous support

From the initial idea through product evolution

Scalable solutions

Technology prepared to grow with you

Availability

Monday - Friday:09:00 - 19:00

Response within 24 hours